When i begun my foray into web-design I actually begun with disassembling a layout and using some of it’s visual elements — enough of them to get me into trouble — a kind person told me to try to go my own way via a private email exchange. at first i took it as insane mumblings. “i devoted hours into reversing the layout to understand the underlying semantics of css and visual design, who does he think he is? ” I thought to myself.
After a rude exchange courtesy of me I begun to understand what he was talking about as one of my own print designs were imitated by a colleague, that led to me being irritated for two weeks and being a constant pain in the butt to everyone in the office who tried to socialize with me whilst engrossed in my own foul mood.
you invest time and a lot of effort into understanding the underlying mechanisms of what makes a design admirable or publicly acceptable to your intended crowd, and some schmuck just rubs you the wrong way and rips the whole damn design off and redresses it into something that frankenstein would hump through eternity. — admittedly, this gutwrenching feeling isn’t something you want to experience. (and personally, i don’t wanna think of that statically charged freak doing the horisontal bugaloo ever again.)
These days it seems like I can’t get through a week without reading about how someone stole this design from this and that person, okay that is something I can live with.
but.
I think it would be more community fostering to discuss the morality of the issue with the person via a private exchange, be it IM or Email, that our community, the Web ecks-dot-ecks-ecks community — for lack of a better word — is a community of F R I E N D S.
I don’t think i’d've gotten the point that Thomas was trying to get across if he wasn’t being as understanding and knowledged on the subject as he is.
We live in a time where p2p reigns supreme — ergo mpaa and riaa pressurecookers — and where it is “sort of” okay to download copyright protected works of content producers (not withstanding the semantics of the whole copyright infringement theatre) young people of today more than anything will not, or do not, understand the issue with what’s not okay about “stealing” someone’s layout/design of a website.
We should frown upon the practice but we must also try to bridge the morality gap and foster an ethical agenda concerning how to best behave when stumbling upon the issue, WASP or another web oriented organization should try to take it upon themselves to further a social agenda within the field — I know AIGA has a charter of this kind –
I don’t think public ridicule — reminiscent of the shame pole of medieval times — is a proper way to go, understanding and education about the subject at hand is however, vital.